Jump to content
The Dark Mod Forums

Recommended Posts

Posted

I'm making this thread to pick up on JackFarmer's recent status update asking where to go after letting Discord go. For those who might not be aware yet, Discord has the intention to roll out age verification (read: identity verification) for its users through uploading government identification or face scans to vendors like Persona, which is backed by Peter Thiel who can be described as "post-democratic" (PCGamer article from February, Wikipedia on Thiel). The public backlash appears to have delayed their plans for now, but it would appear wise for anyone who would not accept such a policy to make plans in good time for when Discord eventually does follow through.

Back in February a small group of mappers and I looked into Discord alternatives and tried out Matrix on a public server. We ran into some technical & user experience issues with Matrix, and ultimately are still mostly on Discord after they walked back their plans and our acute need to migrate went away. I can only imagine that the landscape has improved since then and will continue to do so, and we can make our choice again.

Personally I've gotten into selfhosting a couple years ago, so I have a strong bias to something that is open source and can be hosted on a rented virtual server, since I think that's a solution we can trust and control. I run various self-hosted services internally on various Linux devices with a focus on security and networking, and will eventually take over system admin of the TDM server from taaaki, so I think I would be a in a good position to step up to offering our own chat service. The big "if" I see in this plan, however, is the risk of an EU-wide law coming into force that forces all public chat services to verify age, but in that case we could try to see whether we can select a more benign method (like hand gestures) or whether we can shift responsibility to someone outside of EU jurisdiction.

A publicly hosted service would also be an attractive option since it could have significant advantages when it comes to availability, performance, cost, bus factor, handling legal requirements etc. But then we are reliant on what that entity does, and the question is whether we can actually find such a public service. 

Let's start discussing here. Suggestions for, recent releases or significant updates of alternatives to Discord, which route to take, etc.

  • Like 2
Posted

I think nowadays an instance of the Fediverse is the best alternative (Mastodon, Friendica, Pixelfed, Lemmy, Diaspora.....). Own rules instead those of centralized Big Brother corps, which are killing litle by little the user souvereign and the free internet.

https://fediverse.party

 

  • Like 2

Laptop ACER, AMD Ryzen, GPU AMD Radeon  RAM 16GB, SSD 512GB - Win11 Home 64 v26H2 (Lenguages Spanish, German, English)

Posted

I have not looked into this subject very deeply yet, but I really do not like the Discord client. Their restriction of the usage of other clients is a big disadvantage for me. Matrix seems like a viable alternative on that front. I already found at least two terminal based clients.

As I understand it, to use Matrix you have to get an account from a provider of your choice (like an email address), without the need to give up your phone number.

I'm not sure how to find and participate in whatever its equivalent to a Discord server would be. Some info on how that works would be appreciated.

Posted (edited)
15 hours ago, Dragofer said:

We ran into some technical & user experience issues with Matrix

Can you go deeper into what you encountered?

I found setting up the encyption a little difficult. Although it's optional and maybe it's just me. Also a bunch of the Linux software clients I couldn't get working, but the browser based seemed to work fine.

Edited by datiswous
Posted

gajim is pretty good for an XMPP client, i hear dino should also be quite good. not everything discord did can be replaced but considering the privacy concerns id take something a little more involved any day.

Posted (edited)

Just came across this, so I thought I'd mention it: Harmony, a federated Discord alternative with a Discord bridge for the transition phase. Sounds promising?

Edited by snobel
  • Like 2
Posted

A main reason for me to switch would be free choice of the client. If the alternative just locks me into a different client (that may or may not suck), I don't think I would bother.

Posted (edited)

I was just wondering what the reason is of using chat software in the first place. I think it's because the forum software is not user friendly, especially on mobile.

Would've been easier if it was just markdown or bbcode based, with buttons. Then you can post faster.

This is kind of a different topic (maybe). But for example Forum software Discourse (open source and free when self hosted) also has a chat function build in. So you could use their chat possibly and when the time comes, even start using the forum software.

If you specifically want to use choice of client software/apps, then that doesn't work, but personally I find this less important.

Edited by datiswous
  • Like 2
Posted
5 hours ago, datiswous said:

Then you can post faster.

I don't think that would be conducive (or necessary) to the way a forum works. At least that's how I see it. A forum is useful to exchange and document information, while a messenger/chat is more for socializing.

Posted (edited)

I think that a forum is always better for communication and interaction in is random access structure, not possible this way in social networks wit sequencial structure, where it is easy to loose the theme and you have to scroll up kms to find it. Yes, its mainly for socializing. Forums are dying, despite it is way better and feature rich than a chat, but it was killed by smartphones. In a smartphone the handling of a forum is a toothache, there a chat or social network is easier and more direct.

But for an tech support, there exist nthing better than a forum. Respect Markdown, which I like a lot, would be nice to have instead of the BBcode. But here is needed to maintan the automatic insetion of YT videos, because In Markdown it don't exist like in the BBcode.

Edited by Zerush
  • Like 1

Laptop ACER, AMD Ryzen, GPU AMD Radeon  RAM 16GB, SSD 512GB - Win11 Home 64 v26H2 (Lenguages Spanish, German, English)

Posted (edited)
41 minutes ago, Zerush said:

In a smartphone the handling of a forum is a toothache, there a chat or social network is easier and more direct.

I very often use the forum on my phone and it's really just the forum editor that is a problem, but otherwise it's not so much an inferior experience, except maybe when people write really long texts. I do think a better forum software would possibly keep people more on the forum. Manjaro (Linux os) is using Discourse as their forum software and it's miles ahead of what we have (and my experience with that was at least 2 years ago).

 

2 hours ago, Baal said:

I don't think that would be conducive (or necessary) to the way a forum works. At least that's how I see it. A forum is useful to exchange and document information, while a messenger/chat is more for socializing.

I personally use the forum also for socializing. I don't really see the difference.

Edited by datiswous
  • Like 1
Posted (edited)

I think there's something here that isn't being mentioned about using forum instead of chat which is when someone wants to ask a simple question or just something random that doesn't need its own thread and cluttering the forum with duplicated questions and stuff like that. I know this could be done by creating a thread called random that one could post anything in it but still. This is why i don't see harm in creating a chat server that can be used side by side with this forum. First you could try XMPP public server instead of creating your own to test how it will work. If things turn out alright then you could go ahead to create your own. I'm pretty sure some of them offer a way to create your own group.

Edited by MayheM
Posted

good points from all involved :).

hmm come to think of it the old quake community used IRC for ages but it does require some familiarity with the protocol.

allows simple sharing of files as well.  mumble would also allow voice chats but im not sure video calls are a feature.

https://www.mumble.info/

 

Posted

One thing in this day and age is encryption which had me a little worried in advocating mumble. but if the TDM site hosts the mumble channel it can indeed be encrypted (uses the TLS protocol).

same goes for IRC btw :).

Posted
1 hour ago, revelator said:

allows simple sharing of files as well.  mumble would also allow voice chats but im not sure video calls are a feature.

https://www.mumble.info/

Mumble is great. I have used it before for gaming but it only has a basic text capability and voice chat, and one of its advantages is that it's very light on system, doesn't use a lot of resources, so i am not sure if it's suitable for you guys where you exchange with large files about developing this game.

 

I remember checking when i used it that it uses encryption by default when you host your own server, although i could be wrong.

  • Like 2
Posted

aye the host uses a key certificate for encryption which they can then delegate to trusted users.

sharing big files is not really a problem on the IRC protocol, back in the day the 0day hackers peddled they're stuff on IRC and it worked quite well :) i used it quite often when i was still a member of inside3d. but for something like collaborative work a private SVN or GIT server would probably be better.

Posted
4 hours ago, MayheM said:

Mumble is great. I have used it before for gaming but it only has a basic text capability and voice chat, and one of its advantages is that it's very light on system, doesn't use a lot of resources, so i am not sure if it's suitable for you guys where you exchange with large files about developing this game.

 

I remember checking when i used it that it uses encryption by default when you host your own server, although i could be wrong.

Yes,  the Mumble voice chat works fine, however, the messaging system is inferior.

We (at least the mission makers fraction) need a chat system, the possibility to upload pictures & (smaller) videos, and the possibility to include links. And separate chat rooms (for example, for a WIP in progress or beta testing).

Posted
1 hour ago, JackFarmer said:

Yes,  the Mumble voice chat works fine, however, the messaging system is inferior.

We (at least the mission makers fraction) need a chat system, the possibility to upload pictures & (smaller) videos, and the possibility to include links. And separate chat rooms (for example, for a WIP in progress or beta testing).

Maybe https://matrix.org

Laptop ACER, AMD Ryzen, GPU AMD Radeon  RAM 16GB, SSD 512GB - Win11 Home 64 v26H2 (Lenguages Spanish, German, English)

Posted
54 minutes ago, Zerush said:

Yes, we tried it, and it seems to be what we need. Only problem I had was with the verification (not sure if needed in the first place).

@Dragofer Harmony as per the message from @snobelalso looks promising. I did not know that there is a Fediverse counterpart to discord (shame on me).

Posted

Interesting. I'd be up for a Matrix "server" (what do they call it instead, spaces/rooms?)

I was introduced to Matrix (and Element as its client) from some people in the OpenXcom modding community. It works reasonably well, but yeah you have to be patient especially with first use of it. It's not uncommon at all to miss out on a lot of older messages because they get locked behind encryption and never decrypt. It's still a problem even today, but so long as you get it working and use it somewhat frequently, things work fairly smoothly.

A word of warning, Agent Denton. This was a simulated experience; real LAMs will not be so forgiving.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recent Status Updates

    • JackFarmer

      German Intelligence (BND) just revealed, why MS Outlook is down: even the MS CEO has been seduced by a Chinese spy and the BND just published a convincing picture of the agent:

      Way to go, lads!
       
       
      · 0 replies
    • JackFarmer

      I will NOT return to Discord. Who wants to try something new?
       
      · 12 replies
    • JackFarmer

      I do not understand why Gilmour/Waters trash the "Atom Heart Mother" album and wish for that "all existing copies get dumped".
      I think it is a great recording. Is there something wrong inside my twisted little brain?
      · 3 replies
    • revelator

      Asus ROG strix x570-E gaming ryzen 3700x 32 gb ram radeon RX9070XT 10 tb ssd space (all full)
      · 5 replies
    • The Black Arrow

      I was playing Doom 3, and I learned how to edit maps text-by-text, this should help me a lot with finding secrets and locations I hope.
      That is, if I feel sneaky and greedy...Which I always do, can't get enough 100% a mission.
      · 3 replies
×
×
  • Create New...