Dusk has the Doom gameplay of course, but it's so poor in a good number of design aspects and choices to be a "Doom/Quake killer".
That's what I'm talking, Cultic is just perfect about the *design*, it's Blood on steroids.
If you want the perfect Quake experience just try Arcane Dimensions
And for Doom just try CountryCide: https://www.moddb.com/mods/trench-foot-wip/downloads/countrycide