Jump to content
The Dark Mod Forums

Recommended Posts

Posted

No wonder it was removed. It is against their financial interests to show such a post.

 

Now that you think about it, the existence of standalone TDM is against their interests. *Shivers* I hope there is nothing they can pick up and come after TDM. Aren't we glad IP neutrality was chosen from the start!

Clipper

-The mapper's best friend.

Posted

This comment was not from me but it was the top comment with over 60 likes. Now its gone.

 

Man, it would be nice if people thought before they commented. In no way would we ever want someone promoting TDM by endorsing piracy of Thief 4. That's just idiotic.

Posted

they probably marked it up as spam and when it gets too much spam votes it gets deleted, looked at some of the other posts for spam that are still readable and non of them are technically spam, current spam refer to the game being a clone of either dishonored, assassins creed, or the thief guild stuff you can do in skyrim.

 

I don't like the new Garrett's voice he sounds too weedy.

Posted
Now that you think about it, the existence of standalone TDM is against their interests. *Shivers* I hope there is nothing they can pick up and come after TDM.

There isn't. Also, laches takes care of any legal action they might think of pursuing against TDM.

 

But realistically, it is a non-issue because as far as Square/EM are concerned, TDM is a commercial non-entity. Even if we had ten thousand regular players, it would be nothing close to their profit expectations.

Come the time of peril, did the ground gape, and did the dead rest unquiet 'gainst us. Our bands of iron and hammers of stone prevailed not, and some did doubt the Builder's plan. But the seals held strong, and the few did triumph, and the doubters were lain into the foundations of the new sanctum. -- Collected letters of the Smith-in-Exile, Civitas Approved

Posted

Melan, good to hear.

 

But, still... If the t4 is as bad as it looks, they will be SELLING a product that is inferior to the one we are giving out for FREE!

 

I'm not an economy-man, but I suppose it is fun to explain something like that to the shareholders... At least I wouldn't like to invest into a company like that.Edit, oh and there is the mechwarrior: living legends vs mwomercs example...

Clipper

-The mapper's best friend.

Posted (edited)

If they put a cease and desist on TDM now they would loose a huge chunck of potential customers who would not buy Thi4f out of pure spite. That would also create some really negative publicity as it would look like Eidos, a proffessional game develpment studio, is threatened by a bunch of people making a mod in their spare time. Even if it is true.

Edited by Sir Taffsalot
  • Like 1

"I believe that what doesn't kill you simply makes you... stranger"

 

The Joker

Posted

In no way would we ever want someone promoting TDM by endorsing piracy of Thief 4.

Actually, he was endorsing not pirating it. He just managed to make it a real insult to EM instead of a suck-up. :P
  • Like 2
Posted

That interview surely isn't lifting my spirits.

"Missions usually focus on a single objective." Since when? If they are taking cues from Deus Ex: Human Revolution, you'd think each level would be loaded with multiple objectives. Please do not tell me all the missions will be simplistic get in, steal this, and leave, or some variation of said formula. I'd love to see the return of jailbreaking, and other such things. I'm also open to other new ideas besides Garrett's kleptomania.

Posted

There's a lot of scary things in there, like:

 

Within the framework of Thief, do you think it’s better to let players benefit from a full freedom of exploration that includes mistakes and frustrating moments, or is it more effective to include slight nudges in the right direction for a safer but slightly restrictive experience?

 

SR: On one side, you have the kind of player who demands to jump or go anywhere and die if he or she chooses. Others get bored if they keep dying and don’t mind that kind of stuff being blocked off. What we’re trying to do here is impart subtle messages that certain jumps will kill you—if you still tell Garrett to jump, he’ll instead crouch near the edge and look down.

 

... :(

Posted
A number of the jobs I completed seemed to always involve finding a hidden switch behind a painting

 

Good grief. Let's take a cool idea and make it into a tired cliche.

 

We’ve seen players who don’t even bother to read anything they find. We have to make sure the game is fun for them, too.

 

No, you don't. You tell them to go play a fucking shooter.

  • Like 2
Posted (edited)

...................

Edited by jtr7

A skunk was badgered--the results were strong.

I hope that something better comes along.

Posted
How flexible are the hub jobs? Could a player discover a job item before actually acquiring the contract and turn it in for the reward anyway?

SR: (...) Technically, job items won’t show up until you talk to Basso, because that would otherwise render Basso useless. As an example, you can explore a specific apartment relating to a job before talking to Basso, but the combination for a safe in that apartment holding the job item only appears after you pick up the contract.

Schrödinger's combination.

 

SR: We’ve seen players who don’t even bother to read anything they find. We have to make sure the game is fun for them, too. So, it’s a big challenge to add enough layers of exposition to not penalize anyone who wants to skip over that kind of stuff.

Our target audience: people who don't want to read becuz letterz are teh HARD.

 

Within the framework of Thief, do you think it’s better to let players benefit from a full freedom of exploration that includes mistakes and frustrating moments, or is it more effective to include slight nudges in the right direction for a safer but slightly restrictive experience?

SR: There’s definitely not a black or white answer to this. On one side, you have the kind of player who demands to jump or go anywhere and die if he or she chooses. Others get bored if they keep dying and don’t mind that kind of stuff being blocked off.

Implication: it is the first group of players who are entitled whiners.

 

In Thief, your skillset is demonstrated in different ways. Garrett is a master thief, so he’s really flexible in terms of how he handles situations. You can be fast and aggressive, wiping out an entire room before anyone knew you were there.

Garrett is a master thief, wiping out rooms of people quickly and aggressively.

 

Even though a different team at Eidos Montreal worked on Deus Ex: Human Revolution, what potential lessons did Thief’s team learn from that game’s development and apply towards their own?

SR: Trust your instincts. Human Revolution’s team encountered the same challenges of taking a long established franchise in a new direction while under considerable pressure from core fans going, “No, no, you can’t do that to my Deus Ex.” It’s simply impossible to listen to everybody out there, so the guys working on Thief have really learned to trust their feelings behind their decisions. Nothing would get done otherwise. If we decided to backpedal and add in “taffer” because a bunch of people wanted it, we’d get another complaint the next day from someone else saying, “Why stay stuck in the past?”

One day, someone somewhere would really write that complaint. True story.

 

***

 

Once upon a time, back in 2006 and later in 2008, I wrote a series of posts on a phenomenon I called "the tyranny of fun" - a tendency of reductionist thinking in game design and discourse. I have deleted them due to the sheer amount of harrasment and hate I got for them (I mean, honest-to-goodness hate mail), and because the posts themselves were written in a way that could be construed as more confrontational than really intended, but I think the main points still stand:

  1. Equating 'fun' with 'positive reinforcement' to the neglect of other ways to have it - some of which involve adversity, effort, minor inconvenience or, yes, short/long-term failure.
  2. Redesigning games to codify this understanding of customer satisfaction and cutting elements construed as 'unfun', which makes the game more focused - but also feature-poor and less satisfying for people who have their fun in a different way.
  3. Often wrapped up in rhetorics of 'progress' as inevitable and basically beneficial, traditional gaming practices as an impediment before having fun and appeals to the authority of 'professional game designers'.

If you want it in one sentence:

Fun is a loaded term, and it should not be assumed to mean the same thing to all people.

 

I am reminded of this concept every time I read something new about the way Thief is designed.

  • Like 3

Come the time of peril, did the ground gape, and did the dead rest unquiet 'gainst us. Our bands of iron and hammers of stone prevailed not, and some did doubt the Builder's plan. But the seals held strong, and the few did triumph, and the doubters were lain into the foundations of the new sanctum. -- Collected letters of the Smith-in-Exile, Civitas Approved

Posted

Once upon a time, back in 2006 and later in 2008, I wrote a series of posts on a phenomenon I called "the tyranny of fun" - a tendency of reductionist thinking in game design and discourse. I have deleted them due to the sheer amount of harrasment and hate I got for them (I mean, honest-to-goodness hate mail), and because the posts themselves were written in a way that could be construed as more confrontational than really intended, but I think the main points still stand:

 

[points]

 

If you want it in one sentence:

 

 

I'm probably thick today as I can't understand the points you describe.

 

Do you still have the whole texts? Could you PM them to me, I'd love to read them, because 'fun in gaming' is an interesting topic for me. I promise not to harrass you.

 

I think there exists a comic that is the embodiment of your once-sentence description of fun in gaming:

http://dwarffortress...40/FunComic.png

  • Like 1

Clipper

-The mapper's best friend.

Posted

I have deleted them due to the sheer amount of harrasment and hate I got for them (I mean, honest-to-goodness hate mail)

 

I know I shouldn't be surprised... but, damn.

 

...

 

I think if there was any lingering doubt over whether Thief fans should buy Thief 4, that's been settled by "reading is hard" and "wiping out an entire room before anyone knew". THI4F: Reading is hard, that's my ninja way!

 

Game over. Thread locked.

Posted

Our target audience: people who don't want to read becuz letterz are teh HARD.

:laugh: "Prez sez: School is for loosers" (Simpsons)

FM's: Builder Roads, Old Habits, Old Habits Rebuild

Mapping and Scripting: Apples and Peaches

Sculptris Models and Tutorials: Obsttortes Models

My wiki articles: Obstipedia

Texture Blending in DR: DR ASE Blend Exporter

Posted (edited)

I simply have to thank TDM, and all of the mission creators, for existing in light of how this is developing. It seems they have strayed farther away from the IP than TDM has.

 

I don't wish it to fail, but also hope it won't be eaten up as readily as the Tomb Raider reboot has been by many gamers.

Edited by thrumb

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Recent Status Updates

    • jivo

      I just uploaded a new version of the Visible Player Hands mod. It's been updated for TDM 2.13 and has new animations. Check out the post if you're interested!
      · 0 replies
    • datiswous

      I moved from Manjaro Linux (rolling release) to Linux Mint (LTS). One of the reasons was that I found the updates a bit too often and long. But now on Mint I get updates every day, although they're usually small updates.
      · 3 replies
    • JackFarmer

      "Hidden Hands: Vitalic Fever" - new update available including subtitles & compressed briefing video (thanks to @datiswous) and several fixes.
      · 0 replies
    • Wolfmond

      🇬🇧

      2025-04-20
      I'd like to track my level design progress a bit more often now, so I'm using the feed in my profile here.
      I've been working intensively on Springheel's YouTube course over the past few days. I'm currently up to lesson 8. There is so much information that needs to be processed and practiced. 
      I have started to create my own house. As I don't have the imagination to create a good floor plan, I grabbed a floor plan generator from Watabou and experimented with it. I chose a floor plan that I will modify slightly, but at least I now have an initial idea. 
      I used two guards as a measuring tape: The rooms are two guards high. It turned out that I can simply double the number of boxes in DarkRadiant in grid size 8 that are drawn in the floor plan. 
      I practiced the simplest things on the floor plan first. Drawing walls, cutting walls, inserting doors, cutting out frames, creating VisPortals, furnishing rooms.
      I have had my first success in creating a book. Creating a book was easier than I thought. I have a few ideas with books. The level I'm creating will be more or less a chill level, just for me, where I'll try out a few things. I don't have an idea for my own mission yet. I want to start small first.
      For the cellar, I wanted to have a second entrance, which should be on the outside. I'm fascinated by these basement doors from the USA, I think they're called Bilco basement doors. They are very unusual in Germany, but this type of access is sometimes used for deliveries to restaurants etc., where barrels can be rolled or lifted into the cellar. 
      I used two Hatch Doors, but they got completely disoriented after turning. I have since got them reasonably tamed. It's not perfect, but it's acceptable. 
      In the cellar today I experimented with a trap door that leads to a shaft system. The rooms aren't practically finished yet, but I want to continue working on the floor plan for now. I'll be starting on the upper floor very soon.

      __________________________________________________________________________________
      🇩🇪

      2025-04-20

      Ich möchte nun mal öfters ein bisschen meinen Werdegang beim Leveldesign tracken, dazu nutze ich hier den Feed in meinem Profil.
      Ich habe mich in den vergangenen Tagen intensiv mit dem Youtube-Kurs von Springheel beschäftigt. Aktuell bin ich bis zu Lektion 8 gekommen. Das sind so viele Informationen, die erstmal verarbeitet werden wollen und trainiert werden wollen. 

      Ich habe mich daran gemacht, ein eigenes Haus zu erstellen. Da mir die Fantasie fehlt, einen guten Raumplan zu erstellen, habe ich mir einen Grundrissgenerator von Watabou geschnappt und damit experimentiert. Ich habe mich für einen Grundriss entschieden, den ich noch leicht abwandeln werde, aber zumindest habe ich nun eine erste Idee. 

      Als Maßband habe ich zwei Wächter genommen: Die Räume sind zwei Wächter hoch. Es hat sich herausgestellt, dass ich in DarkRadiant in Gittergröße 8 einfach die doppelte Anzahl an Kästchen übernehmen kann, die im Grundriss eingezeichnet sind. 

      Ich habe bei dem Grundriss erstmal die einfachsten Sachen geübt. Wände ziehen, Wände zerschneiden, Türen einsetzen, Zargen herausschneiden, VisPortals erstellen, Räume einrichten.

      Ich habe erste Erfolge mit einem Buch gehabt. Das Erstellen eines Buchs ging leichter als gedacht. Ich habe ein paar Ideen mit Bücher. Das Level, das ich gerade erstelle, wird mehr oder weniger ein Chill-Level, einfach nur für mich, bei dem ich ein paar Sachen ausprobieren werde. Ich habe noch keine Idee für eine eigene Mission. Ich möchte erst einmal klein anfangen.

      Beim Keller wollte ich gerne einen zweiten Zugang haben, der sich außen befinden soll. Mich faszinieren diese Kellertüren aus den USA, Bilco basement doors heißen die, glaube ich. Diese sind in Deutschland sehr unüblich, diese Art von Zugängen gibt es aber manchmal zur Anlieferung bei Restaurants etc., wo Fässer dann in den Keller gerollt oder gehoben werden können. 
      Ich habe zwei Hatch Doors verwendet, die allerdings nach dem Drehen vollkommen aus dem Ruder liefen. Inzwischen habe ich sie einigermaßen gebändigt bekommen. Es ist nicht perfekt, aber annehmbar. 
      Im Keller habe ich heute mit einer Falltür experimentiert, die zu einem Schachtsystem führt. Die Räume sind noch quasi nicht eingerichtet, aber ich möchte erstmal am Grundriss weiterarbeiten. In Kürze fange ich das Obergeschoss an.



      · 2 replies
    • JackFarmer

      On a lighter note, thanks to my cat-like reflexes, my superior puzzle skills and my perfect memory, I was able to beat the remastered version of "Tomb Raider: The Last Revelation" in a new superhuman record time of 23 h : 35 m, worship me!
      · 5 replies
×
×
  • Create New...